Looking beyond the diagnosis

Used insurance claims to identify depression and anxiety, classify severity, and examine its relationship to healthcare costs.

Highmark Health

Behavioral health was the part of the insurance business everyone treated as pure expense: real money spent, no measurable return. The causes were several — weak analytics, unreliable data, and no trace in the records of how a condition progressed.

The codes could describe severity. In practice, they rarely did.

Counting beyond the code

Relying on diagnosis codes alone left massive blind spots: members treated for depression or anxiety in primary care often never received a psychiatric billing code at all.

So we started by decomposing what the field actually meant by identification and severity — and then dug into the data we really had, with a few analytical teams and a cross-functional group of clinical experts: psychiatrists, psychologists, primary care, ER. They walked us through the clinical workflow, the guidelines, and the realities on the ground — conversations with the people who actually treat these members. It was deep business process analysis, not an analytical exercise.

The result was ID&Strat, Identification and Stratification: members with depression or anxiety identified across the data we had, including the ones the codes missed, and each case graded by severity. About a year of development.

What progression costs

Two years of medical claims showed what no one had priced: as a member’s depression progressed, total cost of care rose with it — not just behavioral health spending, but the whole medical bill. The condition’s trajectory, measured at last.

The first return case

With the condition tracked and its cost measured, the pieces came together as TTBHDT — targeted tele-behavioral health depression therapy: ID&Strat to find and grade the members, a marketing campaign speaking to each severity level in its own language, and the online therapy offering itself. Identification, outreach, treatment — one loop, at a positive ROI.

Outreach to members with depression who weren’t in care was tuned by inferred severity — the language of the message, not the offering, shaped with clinical experts, never intrusive. Some even said it was the first ROI case for BH program they ever saw.

TTBHDT: one email, four tests

Targeted tele-behavioral health depression therapy campaign. Same offer, same email. Only one element changes at a time: the generic wellness version against a message written for the member’s severity.

Each wave tests one element. The winner goes into the next wave.

1
Hook and intro
GenericvsMildModerateSevere
2
Images
GenericvsMildModerateSevere
3
Program benefits
GenericvsMildModerateSevere
4
Key message and call to action
GenericvsMildModerateSevere
Measured:Open rate→Click-through→Sign-up→First session scheduled

The result

ID&Strat changed how the BH practice ran marketing, vendor evaluation, and business cases: one stratification behind outreach, vendor choices, and investment decisions. The framework and its application were published, so other organizations could study and build on the work: Identification and Stratification and Depression and Total Cost of Care.

When you can measure the cost of getting worse, mental health stops being an expense.