Depression and Total Cost of Care

The Cost of Getting Worse

“Association between depression symptom severity and total cost of care: Findings from a large, 2-year, claims-based, retrospective population health study,” Journal of Affective Disorders, 2025.

What the treatment bill leaves out

In discussions about behavioral health spending, a familiar observation kept returning: people receiving care cost more. Treatment generates claims. From that perspective, expanding behavioral health care could look like adding another expense.

Clinicians saw another part of the picture. Depression can disrupt the routines that keep people healthy: attending appointments, following treatment plans, and managing chronic conditions. Helping someone recover could mean more routine care, but fewer crises and costly complications.

That raised a different question: how does the whole healthcare bill change when depression improves or worsens?

Following the condition

A comparison between people with and without a diagnosis could not fully answer that question. Depression varies in severity, and that severity changes over time.

We applied the Identification and Stratification framework to two years of claims and clinical data, examining both depression severity and total medical and pharmacy spending. Nearly 370,000 members could be followed across both years.

The purpose was to move beyond whether depression was present and examine what happened as the condition changed.

The connection to total cost of care

Improvement in depression severity was associated with lower total healthcare spending. Worsening severity was associated with higher spending, while unchanged severity showed comparatively limited movement.

Across the severity transitions reported in the paper, improvement was associated with 6–15% lower total cost of care, and worsening with 25–48% higher costs.

The study established an association rather than testing a particular treatment. Its contribution was to connect changes in depression severity with changes in the broader healthcare bill, providing evidence for evaluating behavioral health care beyond the cost of delivering it.

Severity change and total cost of care
Rows: severity in 2019. Columns: severity in 2020. Each cell: % change in total cost of care, and $ per member per month.
UnknownMinimalMildModerateSevere
Unknown
Minimal
Mild
Moderate
Severe

Pick a cell to see what happened to members whose depression severity changed from one year to the next.

Spending is per member per month. Source: Popkov et al., Journal of Affective Disorders 368 (2025), Figure 2.

What the measurement could miss

The framework assigned each member the highest severity indicated during the year. A severe episode could therefore determine the annual classification even if the person subsequently improved. That makes improvement harder to capture within the measurement period.

More detailed and frequent severity measurements could reveal changes that annual claims-based categories miss. Whether that would produce larger estimates remains a question for further study.

The cost of behavioral health care is visible when treatment is delivered. Understanding its value also requires looking at what happens to the rest of a person’s health.

Publication: “Association between depression symptom severity and total cost of care: Findings from a large, 2-year, claims-based, retrospective population health study,” Journal of Affective Disorders, 368 (2025), 41–47. Published online September 2024. Read the full article.